|
" Digital Quality":
It's
inconceivable that these small dish companies know what this phrase
means.
How have DirecTV
and Dish Network gotten away with the phrase "Digital Quality"
for so long?
I
know that when I've compared picture quality on C-Band to the same
channels on DirecTV or Dish Network, the C-Band picture has far more
information and bandwidth like a DVD, whereas the small dishes showing
the same channels (standard digital, not HD) seemed to have all kinds of
pixel motion and tiling in the background. It's as if there was some
kind of alien virus eating the characters faces and the walls in the
background. This is due to heavy compression schemes that allow these
small dish companies to cram as many channels as possible into the
satellite transmissions and they are quite proud of their result (the
bottom line).
On a basic TV
set, not too many customers even see this lack of bandwidth and they are
content to not have a "snowy" picture. However, for folks with larger
screens, like HD TV sets and projection screens, the basic digital
signals provided by these small dishes is horrendous, yet the
advertising campaigns continue as if "Digital" really did equate
to "studio quality" which is a phrase that long belonged to C-Band.
These little dish companies treat the word "Digital" as if it had
something to do with "quality". Digital is a transmission method and a
way of preserving signal integrity. If these companies would limit the
amount of channels and just send up to satellite what they originally brought
down from C-Band in the first place (without ruining it by compressing
it far too much), then we could say "digital quality" without choking or
laughing.
Let's hope that
as these two companies move from MPEG2 to MPEG4, that they make picture
quality a priority.
That all being
said, I have a 12' dish and a 4DTV which I no longer hold subscriptions
for. Instead, I watch programming on a Dish Network ViP 622 HD DVR. The main
reasoning is due to convenience and the ability to find a reasonable
amount of HD programming (including channels that used to belong to Voom HD) that I can record on the
DVR and watch when I want. If there is nothing on HD and I settle for a
standard digital movie, I have to force myself to ignore picture quality
and try to enjoy the content of the movie regardless of the alien virus
eating away the scenery and the characters. |